Log message #4227477

# At Username Text
# Feb 18th 2020, 02:10 latenal Hi! Is there any redis plug-in?
# Feb 17th 2020, 23:02 k4t \ o /
# Feb 17th 2020, 23:02 k4t finally! I can go sleep!
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:53 k4t thanks!
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:50 k4t ok... that was it ;P
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:46 ndm Oh I didn't really pay attention the first time. I'm not sure if additional route parameters are being included automatically, ie the slug.
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:44 k4t @ndm https://gist.github.com/K4T/646b762ccfece46f5e3d6a45859e8741
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:41 k4t except these 2
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:40 k4t I will remove all routes
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:40 ndm My first instinct would be that there's an additional route connected that catches your URL
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:40 ndm Well, the initial problem is solved, now there's another one :) What other routes do you have connected? Ideally post all the routes and/or the `bin/cake routes` results
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:37 k4t but problem still not solved, I am not getting: /my-editions/view?t=test
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:36 k4t ```public function match(array $url, array $context = []) { $match = parent::match($url, $context); return ($match) ? $match . '/' : false; }```
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:36 k4t Route class fixed:
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:33 k4t ok
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:31 ndm Hence I rest my case :) Fix that, and then go from there and fix the additional problems.
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:30 ndm @k4t When your custom route is asked to do the matching, the first connected route will fail, as it doesn't match the `action`, but since you do not account for that case, and append `/` to whatever `parent::match()` returns, the matching will always be "successful" for the outside world, as the method will always return a string (`false . '/'` equals `/`).
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:26 challgren Im just throwing ideas out at this time
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:26 challgren Kind of how the pages example is https://github.com/cakephp/app/blob/master/config/routes.php#L70
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:26 challgren What about replacing the slug with *?
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:25 ndm The route catching basically everything would be a perfect explanation for the behavior that you described
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:25 ndm I'd say you probably have _additional_ problems, not that the route isn't responsible for the initial problem
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:25 k4t well it will work, but to build correct parameters I will have to add a bit more logic to the code and I wanted to avoid that
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:23 k4t I think that soething is wrong when request contain passed parameters (in my example this is slug)
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:23 challgren Ok since you used a _name what about using that in the link?
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:22 k4t but generally u r right, I should add logic for "false"
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:21 k4t url is still generated wrong
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:21 k4t and I think this is not the problem here, as when I remove my custom Route class from routes
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:21 k4t with one exception - it will add '/' at the end
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:21 k4t my route should do exactly what CakePhP DashedRoute is doing
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:18 ndm @k4t You do not account for non-matching URLs, `parent::match()` can return `false`
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:17 k4t looks like I have to build urls manually ;/
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:16 ndm Well, I don't know what to say about that, I'd have to dig up the discussion in Github. Looking at how `Router::parseRequest()` and `Router::reverseToArray()` return the query arguments in `?`, I'm not sure if I should trust the docs.
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:11 challgren @ndm “Router will also convert any unknown parameters in a routing array to querystring parameters. The ? is offered for backwards compatibility with older versions of CakePHP.”
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:10 k4t oO
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:10 k4t when I remove customer route class and I am on page "/meine-ausgaben/abcd" then HTMLHelper will give me "/my-editions/view?t=test"
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:05 k4t here u can see how routes r defined
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:05 k4t https://gist.github.com/K4T/b8f34b86138d2149e25329e6427b93eb
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:03 challgren Like @ndm said it might be your route connection
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:03 k4t that is what I wanted to ommit
# Feb 17th 2020, 22:02 challgren You might need to specify your action then